FindKoi

New York City, NY

Koi for sale near New York City

Shopping for koi around New York City? Visiting a dealer beats shipping when you can — you see the actual fish, its conformation, and the water it's kept in. Below are dealers elsewhere in New York, and trusted shippers that deliver overnight to New York City. Check the price guide before you go.

Elsewhere in New York

Koi Market

Unclaimed

Dix Hills, NY Ships nationwide $$$ show

Koi Market is a Long Island, New York koi dealer founded in 2008 that grew from a local pond-supply shop into what it calls the largest Japanese koi importer on the East Coast, stocking upwards of 10,000 fish sourced through direct relationships with Japanese breeders. It ships nationwide, maintains a walk-in retail location in Dix Hills, and offers a paid membership tier with shipping perks alongside individually priced championship-line koi that can run into five figures.

  • Sanke Koi

Ships to New York City

Carneys Point, NJ Ships nationwide $$ Ships to NY

Beni Hanna Nishikigoi is a New Jersey koi breeding operation founded in 2017 by koi geneticist Mat McCann on the site of the former Quality Koi Company, which closed in 2016. The farm breeds its own American-bred koi lines alongside imported Japanese stock, describing its approach as genetics-first rather than tied to country of origin, and ships smaller koi overnight while larger fish move via air cargo. It is not affiliated with the original Quality Koi Company beyond sharing the same New Jersey property.

Findlay, OH Ships nationwide $ $$ $$$ Ships to NY

Black Swamp Koi Farms, also operating as Kuronuma Koi Farms, is a Findlay, Ohio koi breeder that describes itself as raising show-quality koi from Japanese parent stock for around 40 years, while also carrying individually imported Japanese fish such as Chagoi and Bekko. The farm ships via UPS next-day air or Delta Cargo for larger koi, handles shipping issues case-by-case rather than with a blanket live-arrival guarantee, and welcomes visits by appointment.

  • Chagoi Koi
  • Bekko Koi

Eustis, FL Ships nationwide $ $$ Ships to NY

Blackwater Creek Koi Farms is a working American koi farm in Eustis, Florida that breeds its own fish from broodstock originally imported from Japan, sold online as US-raised koi and goldfish. It operates two bio-secure farm sites, sells nationwide, and allows appointment-only farm visits where buyers can hand-select fish.

  • Kikokuryu Koi
  • Gin Rin Koi
  • Butterfly Koi
  • Jumbo Koi

Kernersville, NC Ships nationwide $ $$ Ships to NY

Blue Ridge Fish Hatchery (doing business as Blue Ridge Koi & Goldfish) is a fourth-generation family operation based in Kernersville, North Carolina, describing itself as America's largest and longest-running koi and goldfish supplier after more than 60 years breeding fish across six farms with over 200 ponds. It sells standard and premium-grade koi, butterfly koi, and pond goldfish direct to consumers as well as through a retailer network.

  • Butterfly Koi
  • Jumbo Koi

Cali Koi

Unclaimed

North Hollywood, CA Ships nationwide $$$ show Ships to NY

Cali Koi is a North Hollywood, California dealer, founded in 2004, that imports Japanese nishikigoi through relationships its owner built directly with breeders and agents in Japan. Alongside retail koi sales spanning pond-grade to high-end show fish, the business also offers pond and lake management consulting, koi rescue, and pond maintenance and installation services.

  • Kohaku Koi
  • Sanke Koi
  • Showa Koi
  • Goromo Koi
  • +5 more

ChampKoi

Unclaimed

San Jose, CA Ships nationwide $$ $$$ show Ships to NY

ChampKoi (Champion Nishikigoi) is a San Jose, California online koi dealer founded in 1998 by hobbyist-turned-importer Tom Lai. It sells premium Japanese koi hand-selected directly from named Niigata- and Hiroshima-area breeder farms, ships nationwide overnight, and publishes individual breeder profiles so buyers can see which farm produced each fish before purchase.

  • Kohaku Koi
  • Showa Koi
  • Sanke Koi
  • Asagi Koi
  • +5 more

Ocala, FL Ships nationwide $ $$ Ships to NY

Chevy's Quality Koi is a small, owner-operated breeding farm in Ocala, Florida run by Brad, who has built a stable of breeder koi to sell quality, affordably priced fish. The farm ships nationwide on a Monday/Tuesday schedule with shipping cost based on box size and destination, and also welcomes appointment visits to hand-select from its Butterfly and Standard Fin koi, including Kohaku, Kujaku, and Matsuba varieties.

  • Kohaku Koi
  • Kujaku Koi
  • Matsuba Koi
  • Butterfly Koi

La Center, WA Ships nationwide $$ $$$ show Ships to NY

Children of the Sun Koi, doing business as Cots Koi, is a Washington State importer founded in 2004 that sources exclusively from named Japanese breeders including Dainichi, Ikarashi, Maruyama, Izumiya, and Torazo Koi Farms rather than breeding its own stock. It carries Gosanke varieties, Shiro Utsuri, and Ginrin koi across a wide price range, with a live-arrival guarantee that applies to air-cargo shipments but not to UPS shipments. It is included in this Northeast/Midwest research batch even though it is West Coast-based, per the assigned task scope. Note: it competes in the same national import-focused segment as some larger East and West Coast dealers.

  • Kohaku Koi
  • Sanke Koi
  • Showa Koi
  • Shiro Utsuri
  • +1 more

New Hill, NC Ships nationwide $$ $$$ Ships to NY

East Coast Koi Imports operates a 32-acre farm near Durham, North Carolina with over 80,000 gallons of show ponds, mud ponds, and holding tanks. The owner has more than 20 years of experience hand-selecting koi from Japanese breeders, and the business ships nationwide with cost calculated by fish quantity, weight, and destination zip code, in addition to welcoming appointment visits.